RIP NAM

I recently wrote about the role of AI as it comes to forecasting, and the adaptation that will come to numerical modeling. This isn’t a one to one story relationship, but the North American Model, the NAM, which was one of the two primary models for decades (along with the GFS), ran for the last time about a week ago.

The NAM initiated off of data from the GFS at the perimeters, and because it wasn’t as concerned with the global perspective, it was able to get more granular with model output, both spatially and temporally. A drawback, then, was the lack of continuity at the periphery, since it was adopting another model’s information, which led to the accuracy of the model to degrade more quickly than the GFS, even if it was more accurate in the short term.

In the last few years, the WRF, a more local, shorter term model has become popular, particularly in severe weather forecasting, both in the summer and winter,, and this had largely taken over for a lot of the forecast scenarios that the NAM originally served. The WRF can run locally, and does so hourly.

There is still room for a regional model, however, with a higher refresh rate than the GFS, and the replacement model is already running. The RRFS (Rapid Refresh Forecast System) is online, and will serve to cover the ground formerly covered by the NAM. What is really exciting, is that as confidence grows in the models success, it will also eventually replace the WRF.

We will see how well the new forecasting system runs. It’s certainly and indicator that upgrades in compute ability are coming to the weather industry, as the RRFS will take on not only the NAM’s workload but also other models, with different run times and scopes. The NAM was the best known and longest serving, and will be the most notable departure. Undoubtedly, this is consolidation, but it is also progress.

October Forecaster of the Month

We only had a couple of winners this month. Accuweather and The Weather Channel split all the October wins, each picking up 2 1/2 wins in the month. It came down to who did the best on the occasions they weren’t the very best, and in October, it was The Weather Channel by a whisker,

Outlet Forecast Wins (year)
The Weather Channel 12
Accuweather 8.16
Clime 4.66
Victoria-Weather 4.33
WeatherNation 3.66
National Weather Service 2.83
Weatherbug 0.33

Computer overlords

One of the after action reports I saw after Isaias made landfall was that Google’s AI based weather model performed better than most of the traditional numerical models that scientists use. After a moment of reflection on this news, I had one reaction.

Duh.

Discussions of AI are everywhere and are sure to enflame emotions the more you think about it. So let’s talk about what AI is, or at least what it comes from: advances in computer hardware, which in turn leads to faster computing. From a societal or economic standpoint, I’m not an expert on what that would mean. From a meteorology perspective, though, it’s a boon.

Numerical models have existed as long as meteorology has been around. They weren’t particularly useful until computers reduced the time it took to compute the equations that were plugged into the model. The first models were calculated by hand and took 6 weeks to put together. They were more diagnostic than prognostic.

Models have continued to get better and better as computing has gotten better and better. It makes logical sense that the Google AI model, using the best computing software available, should be even better. There are a few caveats to that, however.

First, meteorology will forever be held back by A) a lack of available observations. There simply aren’t enough observations at the surface and certainly not enough aloft to perfectly encompass the atmosphere and calculate it successfully. Even if we did, B) there aren’t enough known equations to solve for all the variables that go into a forecast. There will always be a bit of mystery.

Caveat number two, is that Google AI wasn’t the only one to accurately forecast a more eastward track than most other outlets indicated. For example, there was me. I’m not trying to brag (yes, I am) I am just trying to note that there will always be room for common sense assessments of the weather. There always needs to be someone to communicate, especially in dangerous situations, or situations that aren’t as dangerous as the unfamiliar might believe.

Having the ability to run many more calculations in a much faster time is the essence of building better weather model. I’m an AI skeptic about a lot of things, however meteorology is a perfect use case for it. The ability to run more equations in a shorter time will allow for better model resolution, which in turn can mean better forecasts and increased safety. The compute power of AI is a positive development.

I’m still not getting in a self driving car, though.

September Forecaster of the Month

After a lull in the late summer, The Weather Channel came storming back in September. They were the top outlet in 60% of the forecasts for the month, and manhandled the competition. They have a commanding lead in the forecast wins, but when they’ve been bad, they were really bad, so there is a lot to play for this year. If TWC keeps forecasting like they did in September, they will be hard to catch!

Outlet Forecast Wins (year)
The Weather Channel 8.5
Accuweather 5.66
Victoria-Weather 4.33
WeatherNation 3.66
Clime 3.66
National Weather Service 2.83
Weatherbug 0.33

Hurricane season arrives at last

Well, it’s here. Hurricane Isaias is on the doorstep of the Florida Panhandle, and will make landfall this afternoon to early evening.

Presently, Isaias is a Category 3 hurricane, which is what I anticipated, but it is also taking a bit deeper channel in towards landfall, which at this point appears to be just east of Fort Walton Beach.

While surge is going to be an immediate problem along the coast, within the next few hours, the threat for high wind and a few tornadoes will be pronounced in places like Panama City and Tallahassee. Fortunately, Isaias is moving steadily, and while there is a threat for flash flooding, it is not as severe as we have seen with storms in recent years.

Isaias will march through Alabama tomorrow, which has brought some speculation about the viability of the college football game in Tuscaloosa. It should start drying out fairly early, and football is important at the University of Alabama, so expect it will be a miserable game on.

Isaias is major hurricane and will certainly cause problems in the Panhandle, but it is not as strong as Matthew, the most recent strong hurricane to hit the area, and is not going to dawdle in the high terrain, like Helene. Any landfalling hurricane is notable, and it is particularly notable this year, as it is the first hurricane of any kind in the Atlantic. It only takes one!

Be safe out there.

Hawai’ian History

I just posted about the unusually quiet Atlantic hurricane season. All good there, even a day later. We don’t often talk about the tropical season in the Pacific, because the gyre of the ocean usually keeps storms further to the south, and the general flow of the tropics is east to west, away from the North American mainland. There can be storms that veer poleward, striking the Mexican coast, but the Mexican Pacific is typically quieter than the Mexican Atlantic, particularly the Yucatan Peninsula.

There is one other territory out there, however. Hawai’i sits all by it’s geographic lonesome in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. Typically, hurricanes remain to the south of Hawaii, or never can sustain themselves far enough to the west to afflict the Aloha State. This year, the state has been impacted by two.

Hurricane Lala danced around the the southern coasts of the islands, causing it’s greatest impact to the Big Island, where 4 deaths were attributed to the storm. The greatest issue here was the heavy rain and flooding, though the high winds certainly caused issues of their own, including down power lines in Oahu. On the north side of Hawai’i (the island) one site reported 43″ of rain! While this site was on the north shore, LaLa passed on the south side of the the chain, which is the leeward side of the islands, and does not receive anywhere close to the rainfall seen on the windward side.

Lala was the first hurricane to impact the Big Island since 1871, if that give you an idea of how rare that is. So now that Hurricane Lowell is bearing down on Kauai, this hurricane season is truly remarkable in Hawai’i. Lowell, like Lala, won’t make landfall on the island, but it is forcing the National Weather Service to do something that I don’t know they have ever done: They issued a tornado watch for Kauai and the surrounding waters.

Lowell, as charted from the image pulled from his Wikipedia page, has taken a hard turn to the north towards the islands, and will likely be a hurricane when he makes his pass. Hurricanes often produce tornadoes, but Lala, for example, didn’t have the same rotation and pressure depth Lowell currently does. Given the threat of tornadoes from hurricanes, a watch absolutely makes sense, but Hawai’i’s place in the tropics, and it’s previous ability to avoid tropical storms makes this an incredible rarity.

Also, it’s a lesson for me, even. The Storm Prediction Center only covers the Continental US. Alaska has never had a tornado watch, and until now, neither has Hawai’i, and it was issued by the forecast office in Honolulu.

Lowell will continue to shift north and west. Tornadoes are scary, especially for a part of the world that doesn’t have basements or shelters, however the primary threat, like with Lala, will be rain and flash flooding. Hawai’i contains islands of volcanic origin, so they are filled with rugged terrain and narrow valleys. The leeward side will collect the brunt of the storm, and may sustain significant flood related damage. There will be some surge, but Hawai’i being isolated in the ocean means that water will have other places to go than inland.

Lowell will be off to bother the fish and birds by Tuesday afternoon, and subsequently weaken before hooking back to the east to batter Midway. This is an historic event for the Islands, and a real test for residents there.

No Jinxes

I don’t want to jinx anything. I’ve been around long enough to know that there is no such thing as a jinx, but I also have seen enough that I can’t fully be sure. All that said, it is 4 days until the traditional peak of the north Atlantic Hurricane season. So far, we have seen no hurricanes. The strongest storm was Tropical Storm Bertha, and even I don’t remember that one.

The best part? The outlook remains clear, at least for the next 7 days.

I post this with my typical caveat. Even though the hurricane season has been very quiet thus far, it only takes one storm in the wrong spot to make it much more memorable.